A casual thrift store shopper thought they had picked up just another ordinary coin. What they didn’t realize was that the small, shiny 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar in their hand was about to change their life. Within weeks, this “ordinary” find sold for a jaw-dropping $14 million, shocking collectors worldwide.
The Rare 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar Coin
The Susan B. Anthony Dollar was minted between 1979 and 1981, and again in 1999. While most of these coins are only worth face value, one particular 1999 P mint mark coin turned out to be a rarity. This wasn’t just an average strike—it contained unique errors and characteristics that made it a one-of-a-kind treasure.
A Brief History of the Susan B. Anthony Dollar
Introduced in 1979, the coin honored Susan B. Anthony, the famous women’s rights activist. However, the coin faced public rejection because of its size and resemblance to a quarter. After discontinuation in 1981, it was briefly revived in 1999 to fill a shortage of dollar coins. That revival run produced the legendary thrift store coin that collectors now hail as one of the most valuable in U.S. history.
Timeline of the Susan B. Anthony Dollar
| Year(s) Minted | Mint Marks Available | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1979–1981 | P, D, S | First issue, unpopular with public |
| 1999 | P, D | Final run, rare errors reported |
Why This Coin Sold for $14 Million
So why did this particular coin fetch $14 million? Three main factors:
- Rarity — Only a handful of error-struck 1999 P coins exist.
- Condition — The thrift store find was in near-perfect mint state.
- Collector Demand — High-net-worth collectors compete fiercely for unique U.S. Mint mistakes.
Value Comparison of Susan B. Anthony Coins
| Coin Type | Typical Value | Rare Error Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1979 P SBA | $1 – $10 | Up to $5,000 |
| 1981 S SBA Proof | $50 – $200 | $1,500+ |
| 1999 P SBA (error) | $1 face value | $14,000,000 |
Notable Facts That Will Surprise You
- Most Susan B. Anthony coins are only worth $1, making this find extraordinary.
- The coin sold through a private auction, with multiple billionaires bidding.
- The buyer’s identity remains undisclosed, adding to the coin’s mystery.
How You Can Spot a Valuable Coin
- Check the Mint Mark — Look for “P” (Philadelphia) on 1999 strikes.
- Inspect for Errors — Off-center strikes, doubled dies, or unusual finishes boost value.
- Grading Is Key — Professional grading agencies like PCGS or NGC can certify authenticity and condition.
Expert Insights from Collectors
Coin experts advise that thrift stores, garage sales, and estate sales are often overlooked treasure troves. Many rare coins circulate without notice because their true value is hidden in tiny details most people miss.
FAQs
Q: Are all 1999 P Susan B. Anthony coins worth millions?
A: No, only rare error varieties in exceptional condition hold high value. Most are worth $1.
Q: How can I tell if my coin is rare?
A: Look for unusual minting errors and have it professionally graded.
Q: Where can I sell a valuable coin?
A: Major coin auctions, private collectors, or certified dealers are the best options.
Conclusion: A Lesson in Hidden Treasures
The 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar thrift store find is a reminder that extraordinary treasures can hide in plain sight. What looked like pocket change turned into a $14 million payday. The takeaway? Never underestimate a coin in your wallet, thrift shop, or coin jar—you just might be holding history.